- Citation
- [2026] UKFTT 1348 (TC)
- Tribunal
- First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber)
- Decided
- 24 September 2026
- Judge
- Tribunal Judge Hugo Holmes and tribunal member Susan Stott
HMRC won. A fine-wine importer had claimed SME R&D relief for its year to 31 October 2021, for work with a South African winery on putting fine wine into cans instead of glass, with £43,387.01 in dispute (paragraph 2). The appeal was dismissed, mostly on evidence rather than science. The company did not prove that the testing programme it described had taken place, or that there was a plan (paragraphs 62 and 70). Of the two canning runs it did prove, the one it relied on, 187ml of wine in a 200ml can topped up with nitrogen, was not shown to go beyond a published industry guide that the company itself put in evidence and both sides accepted as the state of the field (paragraphs 35, 79, 87 and 92). Its only witness was its managing director, who told the tribunal he had no particular scientific or technological understanding (paragraph 50(1)). It was decided under the old SME scheme and the 2010 Guidelines. HMRC has not changed its guidance as a result, and the window to seek permission to appeal was open at the review date above.
What was at issue
Whether the company was entitled to relief under Chapter 2 of Part 13 CTA 2009, the old SME scheme, read with the Guidelines on the meaning of research and development (paragraph 3). HMRC accepted that the company was an SME and traded, and disputed only Condition D of section 1044: whether there was any qualifying expenditure at all (paragraph 11). The claim rested on the company’s own staff and on work it said the winery carried out for it, so both routes were in play: R&D the company did itself, under section 1052, and R&D done on its behalf, under section 1053 (paragraphs 15 and 63(1)).
The company imports and distributes fine wines in the United Kingdom, trading as Fine Wines Direct UK. Its stated aim was a high-quality organic wine in a can, for concerts, outdoor events and sports grounds where glass is not allowed. The managing director’s evidence was that canned wine in the UK has to be sold in 187ml measures, so a 200ml can filled to 187ml leaves a space above the wine, the headspace, which has to be filled. The industry guide in the case discusses filling it with gas to stop the wine oxidising (paragraphs 50(5) and 50(20)).
How the dispute got to a hearing
The claim was made by amending the company’s return on 5 October 2022. HMRC opened an enquiry in April 2023 and issued its closure notice, which ends an enquiry and amends the return, on 18 December 2023, requiring £14,972.95 of additional corporation tax and repayment of a £28,414.06 tax credit (paragraphs 2 and 5 to 8). An HMRC review upheld the notice on 31 October 2024, and the company appealed to the tribunal on 20 November 2024.
The appeal (TC/2024/06326) was heard remotely on 2 and 3 July 2026 before Tribunal Judge Hugo Holmes and tribunal member Susan Stott, and released on 24 September 2026. Perry Lewis of Aspen Waite Limited appeared for the company; Max Simpson of HMRC’s Solicitor’s Office for HMRC.
The managing director was the only witness: the company was given 14 days from 18 May 2026 to file statements from anyone else, and filed none. The rest of its case was chiefly documents: four letters from the winery, three undated and one dated 26 June 2026 and put forward three days before the hearing; emails and an invoice for a large wine order placed in November 2022; the industry guide; and the claim report prepared by its representatives (paragraphs 35 to 45).
What each side argued
The company’s case was that it instructed the winery in May 2021 to develop fully recyclable packaging, based on canning, that kept fine wine to its taste standards (paragraphs 50(4) and 54(2)). Until November 2022, it said, the winery tested different can linings, wines and headspace gases, sending samples to tasting meetings at the company, and none met its standard (paragraph 50(6)). It then placed a large order on the winery’s assurance that the process worked. The winery could not deliver in 200ml cans and filled imported 187ml cans instead, which the company said kept the wine for too short a time (paragraph 50(9) to (11)).
The advance claimed was a way of storing fine wine in a fully recyclable container that does not use glass, which the company said the industry had not yet achieved (paragraph 75). The people it put forward as competent professionals, those with the expertise to say what the field already knew, were the winery and another director said to have particular expertise in wines (paragraphs 37 and 81).
HMRC’s case was that the account was not proved. The letters and the managing director’s evidence were memories reconstructed years later, and the documents produced began in November 2022 and showed a wine order. A failed test in May 2021 was unlikely, because the company would then have ordered wine in packaging it already knew did not work (paragraph 55). Any experimenting improved the company’s own knowledge, not the field’s (paragraph 76).
The provision the case turns on
Condition D of section 1044 CTA 2009 required the company to have “qualifying Chapter 2 expenditure” (paragraph 10). Under section 1052 that expenditure had to be “attributable to relevant research and development undertaken by the company itself”; under section 1053, “attributable to relevant research and development undertaken on behalf of the company” (paragraphs 13 and 14).
The statute does not define R&D itself. Through section 1138 CTA 2010, section 1006 ITA 2007 and SI 2004/712 it hands the definition to the Guidelines, which both sides agreed have the force of law (paragraphs 16 to 19). The tribunal relied chiefly on four of their paragraphs, quoted at paragraphs 21 to 28 of the decision. Under Guidelines paragraph 3, R&D “takes place when a project seeks to achieve an advance in science or technology”. Paragraph 6 requires an advance in overall knowledge or capability in a field, not in the company’s own alone. Paragraph 19 makes a project “a number of activities conducted to a method or plan in order to achieve an advance in science or technology”. Paragraph 20 defines the field’s overall knowledge as what “is publicly available or is readily deducible from the publicly available knowledge or capability by a competent professional working in the field”.
What the tribunal decided
The tribunal started with the facts, because the parties agreed on very few of them. The company had to prove what it relied on as more likely than not. HMRC did not allege dishonesty, and the tribunal said that failing to meet that standard “is not the same thing as concluding that there was dishonesty in the evidence” (paragraph 52).
It found that the relationship with the winery began “in or shortly before November 2022” (paragraph 56). The company produced no correspondence with the winery dated between May 2021 and October 2022, and no invoice or contract for its services in that period. The emails produced began on 2 November 2022 with no reference to earlier work, and the winery’s internal email called the company a “new client”. Apart from the main production run in 2023, there was one canning run, 187ml of wine in 200ml cans with nitrogen in the headspace, in or after November 2022 (paragraphs 57 and 58).
The testing programme was not proved (paragraph 62). Its only written account was the 26 June 2026 letter from the winery’s chief executive, which the tribunal gave “very little weight”. The letter was written from memory more than three years after the events, shortly before the hearing, following a meeting with the managing director and the company’s representative. Its author did not give evidence, so it could not be tested by questioning, and it described trials of different linings and gases that the earlier letters never mentioned (paragraph 60(3)). The tribunal was “not casting any aspersions” on the author’s honesty; its finding was “based on the fallibility of memory” (paragraph 60(3)(f)). Instructions to the winery, notes of the tasting meetings, internal messages, feedback, invoices and a contract were all “entirely absent from the evidence before us” (paragraph 60(3)(j) and (k)).
The company’s own part fared no better. The claim included £139,188 of salaries and wages for its own staff, and the company produced no document showing any of them doing the work. The claim report put the managing director at 35% of his time. Yet on his own estimates of 20 to 50 wines tasted a week and 30 to 40 samples from the winery in all, HMRC put the winery’s share of the tasting at about 4%. He accepted that 35% may have been too high, and the tribunal called the gap “a significant mismatch” (paragraphs 50(19) and 63).
What was proved was a wine order in November 2022, a canning run in 200ml cans whose wine did not meet the company’s requirements, and a second run in imported 187ml cans in April and May 2023 (paragraph 64). Nothing else was.
On the plan, the tribunal found nothing it could rely on. The only accounts of one were the managing director’s evidence and the 26 June 2026 letter, and it had already found that the testing they described was not proved (paragraph 67). The company produced no planning correspondence, no records of failed tests and nothing setting out a next approach in the light of results (paragraph 68). It had therefore “not shown any systematic approach that would constitute a ‘method or plan’” (paragraph 69).
On the advance, the tribunal left the second run out of account, because the company did not suggest the imported cans were experimental. That left the 200ml run, and the question of what a competent professional in the field already knew. No witness gave that evidence. The managing director “was frank that he did not have any technological or scientific expertise”; neither the director put forward as the wine expert nor anyone from the winery gave evidence (paragraphs 79 to 84).
So the tribunal used the one statement of the field before it: “The Winemaker’s Guide to Wine in a Can”, which the company had put in evidence and both parties agreed represented the state of knowledge in winemaking (paragraph 35). Anything within it is not an advance (paragraph 86). It discusses filling a can’s headspace with nitrogen, and the managing director did not explain clearly how the company’s work differed. He said that sealing 187ml of wine in a 200ml can with inert gas was something no one else was doing (paragraph 50(20)). Following the High Court in BE Studios Ltd v Smith & Williamson Ltd [2005] EWHC 1506 (Ch), the tribunal held that “uniqueness, or novelty, is not the relevant test”, and found the company had not shown its work went beyond what a competent professional could readily deduce (paragraphs 87 and 92(1)).
Nor did the company show that the work was done in order to achieve an advance. According to one of the winery’s letters, no 187ml cans were available in South Africa, and the emails show 200ml was a standard size there (paragraphs 89 and 91). The company wanted the wine canned in South Africa because shipping it by tanker for canning in the UK would affect the taste. Filling 200ml cans with extra nitrogen was “simply a result of wanting to ensure canning occurred in South Africa”: a commercial choice, not a step towards an advance (paragraphs 91 and 92(2)). The appeal was dismissed (paragraph 94).
What HMRC did afterwards
Nothing, on the published record as at the review date above. The change log of HMRC’s R&D guidance manual (the CIRD manual), checked on 26 October 2026, has no entry after 25 August 2026, and the decision cites no CIRD paragraph. The only change in the 2023 to 2026 log that HMRC attributes to tribunal decisions is still the 27 February 2025 amendment of CIRD81650 and CIRD84250.
What it changes for a claim being prepared now
- Keep the record while the work runs. The finding was that the testing was not proved, not that it never happened. Instructions, test notes, results and invoices made at the time are what the tribunal looked for and did not find (paragraph 60(3)(j)).
- A letter written for the appeal can carry very little weight. One drafted from memory years later, shortly before the hearing and after a meeting with the company and its representative, by someone who did not give evidence, carried very little here (paragraph 60(3)). Where a contractor does the technical work, keep the contract and invoices, and make sure someone from the contractor can give evidence.
- A baseline can be used against you. The guide the company put in became the measure, and it already discussed filling the headspace with gas (paragraph 87). A claim that cites a published baseline has to say exactly what the work did beyond it.
- Separate the commercial decision from the technical question. The can size followed from where the wine was canned. Doing something nobody else is doing does not make it R&D.
- Time percentages need records behind them. The managing director accepted that the 35% attributed to him may have been too high.
For accounting periods beginning on or after 1 April 2024 the merged scheme applies, or Enhanced R&D Intensive Support for a loss-making SME whose relevant R&D expenditure is at least 30% of its total relevant expenditure. The definition of R&D did not change with the schemes. The 2010 text of the Guidelines applied here; the 7 March 2023 revision, which governs both current schemes, carries the same wording in the paragraphs quoted above, and a current claim needs the same evidence.
If your company has filed a claim whose evidence is mostly letters and recollections put together after the event, our six-point claim review will read it against the same tests. It is free and confidential, and there is no obligation to take anything further.
Where it sits against the other decisions
It quotes Beer Express and AHK Recruitment and adopts them as summaries of what a claimant has to prove (paragraphs 30 to 32). From Flame Tree Publishing it takes the description of a competent professional that HMRC put to that tribunal and that tribunal endorsed (paragraphs 32 and 74). Beer Express is the closest on the facts: there, too, the only witness was a director who could not speak for the technical work, and reports whose author did not give evidence counted for nothing. Here the late letter from the winery’s chief executive, the only written account of the testing, counted for very little (paragraph 60(3)); the tribunal still used the winery’s letters, read against the emails, to find the canning run that did take place (paragraph 57).
On novelty it relies on BE Studios, a 2005 High Court negligence claim against accountants that this register names without an entry of its own. On memory it applies Cry Me A River Ltd v HMRC [2022] UKFTT 517 (TC) and, through it, the High Court’s warning in Gestmin that preparing for litigation reshapes recollection (paragraphs 34 and 60(3)).
It cites neither Tanglewood Care Services nor Environmental Services, released seven weeks and two weeks before it, but it sits beside them. Environmental Services failed because the work was practical problem-solving for the company’s own operations and nobody set out the field’s baseline (Environmental Services at paragraphs 90 and 95); here the baseline was agreed, and the company did not show that the proved work went beyond it. Tanglewood held that a plan need not be formally documented and Environmental Services accepted one that was never written down, and this tribunal did not say otherwise. Its point was evidential: the only accounts of a systematic approach were the managing director’s recollection and the late letter, and with no contemporaneous record behind them they did not prove one (paragraphs 67 to 69).
Has it been appealed?
No onward appeal has been reported as at the review date above, and no Upper Tribunal decision naming the company appears on the published record. An application for permission “must be received by this Tribunal not later than 56 days after this decision is sent” (paragraph 95). The decision does not say when it was sent; it was dated and released on 24 September 2026, so the 56 days run to 19 November 2026 at the earliest. Applications for permission are not published. This entry is diarised for re-check after that date.
This is a First-tier Tribunal decision on its own facts: it binds only the parties, sets no precedent and puts no sector, drinks included, outside the relief. The same qualification applies to the other First-tier decisions in the R&D case-law register.
Sources
- RDM Wines Ltd v HMRC — [2026] UKFTT 1348 (TC), printed on its face as [2026] UKFTT 01348 (TC); TC 10019; TC/2024/06326; heard 2 and 3 July 2026; released 24 September 2026. All unattributed paragraph numbers refer to it, verified against the Akoma Ntoso XML. The decision’s own cross-references run one number behind its published numbering (its reasons on the 26 June 2026 letter are cross-referred to as “[59(3)]” and sit at paragraph 60(3)); the pins above follow the published numbering.
- Section 1044, section 1051, section 1052 and section 1053 CTA 2009 — as at 31 October 2021, the last day of the period in issue. The old SME scheme they set out applies only to accounting periods beginning before 1 April 2024.
- Section 1138 CTA 2010, section 1006 ITA 2007 and regulation 2 of SI 2004/712 — the definition chain.
- Guidelines on the meaning of research and development for tax purposes — the current version, updated 7 March 2023, which replaced the 2004 Guidelines as updated 6 December 2010 that applied here. Its paragraphs 3, 19, 6 and 20 carry the wording quoted at paragraphs 21, 22, 27 and 28 of the decision respectively.
- CIRD manual change log — checked 26 October 2026; latest entry 25 August 2026, none attributed to this decision.
- “The Winemaker’s Guide to Wine in a Can”, by Dr Carien Coetzee, published by Basic Wine and the Wine Industry Network of Expertise & Technology — the guide both parties accepted as the field’s state of knowledge (paragraph 35). Not linked: the version before the tribunal was undated, and the decision does not identify it further.
- Beer Express Ltd v HMRC — [2026] UKFTT 672 (TC) at [94], quoted at paragraph 30 and adopted at 32; AHK Recruitment Ltd v HMRC — [2020] UKFTT 232 (TC) at [68], quoted at paragraph 31 and adopted at 32; Flame Tree Publishing Ltd v HMRC — [2024] UKFTT 349 (TC), the formulation HMRC put at [66] and that tribunal endorsed at [68], quoted and adopted at paragraphs 32 and 74; BE Studios Ltd v Smith & Williamson Ltd [2005] EWHC 1506 (Ch) at [45] and [46], cited at paragraphs 33 and 87; Cry Me A River Ltd v HMRC [2022] UKFTT 517 (TC), Hargreaves v HMRC [2019] UKFTT 244 and Gestmin SGPS SA v Credit Suisse (UK) Ltd [2013] EWHC 3560 (Comm), at paragraph 34.
First-tier Tribunal decisions bind only the parties to them and set no precedent. This entry describes the decision as it stood at the review date above, as general information rather than advice on your circumstances — see our terms. For an answer on your own facts, talk to us.